Monday, November 16, 2026

A benefit of kicking Canvas to the curb: A reconsideration of Alternative Grading

Regular readers may recall that, for this semester, I have kicked Canvas to the curb. I am using an edupunk collection of techniques to manage my courses. I would like to write more about the project, but for today, I want to focus on one particular and unexpected outcome.

I am using triage grading as usual in CS222 and parts of CS315. For the uninitiated, this is a model where an assignment (or part of an assignment) is graded on a four-point scale. Being essentially correct earns three points, being essentially incorrect earns one, and anything in between earns two, with zero points earned for unsubmitted work. These points can readily be added together and manipulated in order to determine composite grades such as final course grades. When my students access their grading record, they can see something like "2/3" or "3/3" for each assignment. However, it wasn't clear to me that everyone remembered or understood what these meant. That is, another way to read those grades would be "Try again" and "Good enough." It struck me that these descriptions are what a lot of Specifications Grading revolve around.

In triage grading, the numbers were always secondary anyway. The real meaning of a three-out-of-three is "essentially correct." The only reason it gets a number is to be able to do manipulations. Canvas makes it easy to enter the numbers and essentially impossible to do anything else: Canvas insists that grades are made up of points. But I don't have to follow that any more.

The spreadsheets I made to track student grades primarily store numbers, but they don't have to either. I could instead store rubrics directly and encode whatever transformation I want to spit out an A-F grade at the end. I don't have to abide by others' assumptions about how grades ought to work.

I am free to pursue specifications grading or other alternative grading techniques.

I have started working on Spring course plans in earnest, beginning with what may be the most complicated one: CS390 Game Studio Preproduction. My current draft embraces specifications grading wholeheartedly without my having to fuss over how I would represent the various assessments in Canvas. Radical that I am, now I am wondering how far I can take this inspiration.