Wednesday, February 16, 2022

"What do you call this kind of game?" and other questions

Over the weekend, I was with a friend whose family enjoys games like Catan and Carcassonne but who one would not call "in the hobby." At one point, he brought out Mice and Mystics and Lord of the Rings: Journeys in Middle Earth, which he had bought at the FLGS but never was able to really get into. He mentioned feeling like the rulebooks were written for people who knew something he didn't know, which is a fascinating observation: it makes me want to study rulebook readability and its relationship to games literacy. My friend mentioned that he had wanted to try one of these two (I cannot remember which) with his family, so they sat down together to play, opening the box for the first time then and looking at the rules. This, too, is fascinating to me. As a hobbyist, I would never do that, but it's a completely reasonable thing for an intelligent layperson to do.

My friend pointed to the boxes and asked, "What do you call this kind of game?" I understood the question and was stunned at my own inability to reply. Now, if it had been Runebound or Mage Knight, I would have said, "Fantasy adventure game," or if had been Descent, I would have said, "Dungeon Crawl." The two games he had on the table are kind of strange hybrids of these. One could certainly go to the FLGS and say, "Please show me a game like Mice & Mystics," but I did not really have an answer for him as to what to call such a game from first principles. When I talk to hobbyists friends, we often refer to games as constellations of mechanisms, like "deckbuilding strategy miniatures game," but that's basically jargon. 

Puzzling over the conversation, I am left with several questions. Is there a useful nomenclature for games that non-hobbyists can use, or were his problems with these two games really because you must experience a rite of passage into the hobby in order to approach them? What knowledge do I have, that was assumed in the presentation of the rules, that he does not have? How can one design a box to convey the idea that the purchaser should open the box, explore the contents, read the 20+ pages of rules, and probably watch an introductory video before sitting down to actually play it with people?