By virtue of receiving the inaugural Teacher of the Year award from the College of Sciences and Humanities, I was invited to give some remarks at the Dean's Honor Reception. The reception is later this morning, and these are the remarks I intend to give. I will be working from notes, not this written form, so the precise delivery will certainly vary, but these are the main points. Also, the original title for the talk was "The End of Higher Education," which was a pun on the two meanings of "end," but it was softened to "The Goal of Higher Education."
In preparation for this talk, I read through two of the notebooks I keep whenever I read a book. It was purely delightful: it's like someone wrote a book that contained only things that I find fascinating, inspiring, or challenging. I hope that you also keep notes when you read. It will bring you joy to read them later, and it will fight against that persistent human fallacy, "I will remember this."
I searched my notebooks for an answer to the question, "What is the goal of higher education?" I am sure you have your own answers, perhaps dealing with careers or impact on the world. In the Republic, Plato asserts that the goal of higher education is to love what is beautiful. I think he's right. You might ask, "How do we come to recognize beauty?" To this, I would assert that beauty is already out there, and so the question becomes, "How do we fail to recognize beauty?"
Gollum was not free to recognize beauty. Gollum could only see the One Ring. Because he was distracted by this created thing, he was blind to the beauty around him. The Tolkien scholar Joseph Pierce talks about how we can all become Gollumized. We can become so distracted by things that we fail to see beauty, that like Gollum, we lose the freedom to recognize it.
Interestingly, German philosopher Martin Heidegger wrote that we are not free if we believe that technology is morally neutral. Heidegger recognized that humanity has always used technology, but he said that we are not free if we think of this technology as neutral. Take the humble hammer as an example. With a hammer, I can pound nails, but remember the old saying, "When all you have is a hammer, every problem looks like a nail." It's true. The hammer has moral agency. That is to say, the hammer affects the moral decision space that you are in. With a hammer in hand, striking things with it becomes an option. The hammer has moral agency. How much more so the smart phone?
Canvas is a technology. Canvas affects your moral decision space. Canvas color codes your grades so that you "know how well you are doing." Canvas gives you notifications, so that you stop what you are doing and pay attention to it. Canvas gives you confetti when you turn in work on time. Beware. Larry Muller, in his brilliant book The Tyranny of Metrics, writes about how the calculative is opposed to the imaginative.
How is one to find beauty if one steps away from the calculative? I have time to share with you three stories.
My friend Dannie was an undergraduate architecture major here back in the 1990s. He asked on of his professors, "How am I doing in this course?" expecting a quantitative answer. The professor took out a piece of paper and, along a line, drew an egg, a tadpole, and then a frog. He pointed to a spot on the line and said, "You're about here." Now that is a midsemester grade!
Last weekend, I ran Global Game Jam here on campus. This is an event where people get together and, in 48 hours, create original videogames. We had over 40 people attend, mostly Ball State students but also students from other places as well as community members. There was no judging, there were no grades, there were no prizes, there was no competition, yet at the end, we had made eight original videogames, which are now available to the world for free. We made them for the joy of creating them and the pleasure of sharing them. This event is a global event, and all together, this community created over 11,000 games, just for the sake of beauty.
I regularly teach a required sophomore-level programming class. In this class, I use a system called "achievements", inspired by video games, that let students earn course credit by doing things that are outside the normal course expectations. One of the options is called, "Detox," and it requires a student to go 24 hours without looking at a screen. Every semester, a few students try it, and their essay responses would make you weep. Students have told me how they walked across campus and really heard the birdsong for the first time. Others write about how they reflect on their life, how they got to where they are, and their hopes and dreams. My favorite story is of a student who, instead of doomscrolling on Instagram, took her grandmother for coffee. There is nothing better than that.
I put it to you that beauty is all around us—well, unless you work in the Robert Bell Building, like I do, but we're doing our best.
Look at the people on stage here. They are beautiful. Look at the people sitting next to you or behind you. Really! Do it! They are beautiful.
Speaking for myself, I don't care what grades you get. I want you to find your One Ring—because we all have them—cast it into the fires, and then join me life's great adventure of loving beauty.
No comments:
Post a Comment